Geothermal Power on the Rise

Geothermal power generation capacity worldwidetwo decades (1960-1980) was due to a single
rose from 7,972.7 MW in 2000 to 8,933 MW inutility's development of one dry-steam resource.
2005, with 8,035 MW running. This is about 0.2%After 1983, growth shifted toward independent
of the total world installed power generatingpower producers and development of
capacity.waterdominated geothermal resources at several
The geothermal heat pump (GHP), also known aslocations.
the Ground-Source Heat Pump (GSHP) orThe steady growth of geothermal development in
generically as geoexchange, is the fastest growingthe United States from 1960 to 1979 was led by
geothermal application today. GSHP is a highlyactivities at The Geysers, where the field
efficient renewable energy technology that isdevelopments of the partnership of Union Oil
gaining wide acceptance for both residential andCompany of California, Magma Energy Company,
commercial buildings, with 1.4 million installationsand Thermal Power Company were greatly
worldwide by 2005, and growth from 1,854 MWtexpanded toprovide steam to the Pacific Gas and
of capacity in 1995 to 15,284 MWt in 2005.Electric Company (PG&E) electrical-generation
Ground-Source Heat Pumps are used for spacesystem.
heating and cooling, as well as water heating. TheThis construction made The Geysers field the
technology relies on the fact that the Earthlargest geothermal development in the world.
(beneath the surface) remains at a relativelyProduction from The Geysers peaked in 1988 but
constant temperature throughout the year,pressure declines in the reservoir limited any
warmer than the air above it during the winterfurther expansion of the field. In December 2006,
and cooler in the summer. GSHP systems doit was announced that the 55 MW Bottle Rock
work that ordinarily requires two appliances, aGeothermal Power Plant at The Geysers will
furnace and an air conditioner and use 25%-50%reopen after being dormant since 1990. It will
less electricity than conventional heating or coolingoperate initially at 20 MW with plans to expand.
systems.Geothermal well drilling has tapered off in the US
Geothermal technology is suitable for integratedsince the 1980s. In California, four wells were
regional energy systems, rural electrification anddrilled in 1996 (one at The Geysers and three at
mini-grid applications, especially in distributedSalton Sea), nine in 1997 (four at Coso, two at
generation systems, in addition to national gridThe Geysers and three at Salton Sea) and seven
applications. It is being promoted as a regionalin 1998 (three at Coso, one at The Geysers and
resource, combining the exploitation of renewablethree in the Salton Sea). In all, between 1996 and
energy resources together with environmental1998, only 13 production and seven injection wells
advantages.were drilled in California. The most promising new
Geothermal energy is contained in the heatedareas for geothermalexploration are in Hawaii and
rocks and fluid that fill the fractures and poresthe Cascade Mountains of Washington, Oregon,
within the earth's crust. It can be harvested inand northern California.
two ways, direct use of hot water or steam forFuture developments are planned, with projects
space heating or industrial use such as aquaculture,being considered in some 55 stages. Not all of
thermal baths and hot springs, and to powerthese will happen since some are in the
electricity generation plants. Direct use is confinedpre-planning phase and others are awaiting
to low temperatures, usually below 150o Capproval. The opinion in the geothermal industry in
whereas, power generation employs highthe US is up-beat for future expansion.
temperature resources over 150o C. 80 countriesPhilippines
have developed direct use of geothermal energyThe Philippines is the second largest geothermal
and 20 exploit geothermal energy for powerpower generating country in the world after the
generation. Direct low-temperature use employsUSA, with installed capacity of 1,930 MW at the
about twice the energy capacity as is used forend of 2005, of which 1,838 MW was operational.
power generation.The Philippines now leads the world in terms of
Direct use of geothermal heat has been used forwet steam field capacity and ranks just behind
thousands of years. The major direct usethe US in terms of geothermal power generation.
applications today are GSHP installations for spaceThe Philippines is located in the Pacific Rim of Fire,
heating, presently estimated to exceed 500,000a volcanic region which extends in a crescent
and are the first in terms of global capacity butfrom Sumatra in Indonesia at the western end,
third in terms of output. Direct use of geothermalacross the 3,000 mile archipelago of Indonesia,
energy achieves 50-70% efficiency, comparedthrough the Philippines archipelago to Japan in the
with the 5-20% efficiency achieved with theeast. It has a considerable number of high quality
indirect use of generating electricity.geothermal resources. These are all island arc
Geothermal power started in 1904 with thevolcanic systems as typically found in the
Larderello field in Tuscany, which produced theCircum-Pacific region, and show close similarities
world's first geothermal electricity. Majorwith geothermal systems in Indonesia and Japan.
production at Larderello began in the 1930s andThe widely distributed nature of the geothermal
by 1970; power capacity had reached 350 MW.resources in the Philippines has long been an
The Geysers in California started in the 1960s isimpediment to geothermal power development.
the largest geothermal plant in the world. IndividualWith over 20 years of experience in geothermal
geothermal power plants can be as small as 100development and power generation, the
kW or as large as 100 MW depending on thegeothermal industry in the Philippines is now in a
energy resource and power demand.mature state and currently the Philippines
The three countries with the largest amount ofDepartment of Energy is supervising the
installed direct heat use capacity are USA (5,366operations of nine geothermal service contract
MW), China (2,814 MW) and Iceland (1,469 MW),areas. In the early 1990s, there was a rapid
accounting for 58% of world capacity, which hasupswing in geothermal power development and
reached 16,649 MW.1,000 MW of geothermal capacity was added
The global installed capacity of geothermal powerbetween 1993 and 1997. This was largely due to
generation at in December 2005 was 8,933 MW,BOTlegislation in the Philippines, which allowed
of which 8,035 MW was operational. Six countriesinternational power utilities to enter the market
accounted for 86% of the geothermal generationand to fund and construct geothermal power
capacity in the world. The USA is first with 2,564plants. This enabled an increase in the much
MW (1,935 MW operational), followed by Philippinesneeded generating capacity without increasing
(1,931 MW, 1,838 MW operational); four countriesnational debt.
(Mexico, Italy, Indonesia, Japan) had capacity atThe Philippine government plans to add 526 MW
the end of 2005 in the range of 535-953 MWof new capacity between 2002 and 2008.
each. Mexico and Indonesia have grown 26% andIndonesia
35% respectively between 2000 and 2005.Development of geothermal potential has
Although on a smaller base, Kenya achieved theproceeded very slowly in Indonesia and is
highest growth, from 45 MW to 129 MW.currently facing difficult challenges and uncertainty.
In the last five years geothermal powerOver a span of 20 years, Indonesia has
generation has grown at an annual rate of 2.3%developed only 797 MW of geothermal power,
globally, a slower pace than the 3.25 in theapproximately 4% of 20,000 MW geothermal
previous five years, while direct heat use showedpotential. In the early 1990s, eleven contracts for
a strong increase. With current technology, thedevelopment of geothermal power plants were
global potential capacity for geothermal generationawarded, with a total committed capacity of
is estimated at 72,500 MW and at 138,100 MW3,417 MW and original completion dates between
with enhanced technology.1998 and 2002. As a result of the 1997-1998
A strong decline in the USA in recent years, duefinancial crisis, which brought PLN, the state utility
to over-exploitation of the Geysers steam field,to technical bankruptcy, the Government
has been partly compensated by importantsuspended nine conventionally powered IPPs and
additions to capacity in several countries: Mexico,seven geothermal projects. The government is
Indonesia, Philippines, Italy, New Zealand, Iceland,now attempting to resuscitate the seven
Mexico, Costa Rica, El Salvador and Kenya.contracts butwith little progress.
Newcomers in the electric power sector areThe new oil and gas law, passed in October 2001,
Ethiopia (1998), Guatemala (1998), Austria (2001)bars geothermal as an area of regulation, requiring
and Nicaragua.the Indonesian Government to develop a new
In 2005 and 2006 the United States showedlegislative basis quickly. PLN understands that the
strong signs of renewed growth for geothermalfuture of geothermal power will depend on its
power generation. Five states now havecompetitiveness against other means of electricity
geothermal power generating facilities; California,generation. High capital costs and the associated
Nevada, Utah, Alaska and Hawaii. The Richardelectricity tariff required remain core problems. In
Burdett Power Plant (formerly Galena I) in Nevadaaddition, unresolved decentralization issues,
commenced generating power in 2005 and theuncertainties in security and contracts, and the
first geothermal power plant in Alaska beingpotential regulatory changes of a planned
installed in 2006 at Chena Hot Springs. A fairlygeothermal lawdiscourage investment in
extensive list of projects has beenannounced forgeothermal projects. In the long run, Indonesia still
the next ten years, with new installations plannedpresents one of the world's most attractive
in Arizona, Idaho, New Mexico and Oregon, ingeothermal regions, but the Indonesian
addition to the existing five 'geothermal' states.Government must develop new approaches to
Japan, Philippines and Nicaragua have all announcedmaximize its potential.
ambitious plans for further development ofPLN is currently negotiating to bring down tariff
geothermal power.rates on various geothermal ESCs, with the intent
There are three basic technologies for generatingof lowering prices from US ¢ 6-8 cents/kWh
electricity from geothermal energy. Dry steamagreed under Power Purchase Agreements
power plants using dry steam systems were the(PPAs) to around US ¢4 cents/kWh. The
first type of geothermal power generation plantsoriginal prices negotiated by the geothermal
to be built. They use the steam from thedevelopers ranged between US ¢7.25-9.81
geothermal reservoir as it comes from wells andkWh, about double the viable rate.
route it directly through turbine/generator units toItaly
produce electricity. Flash steam plants are theItaly is one of the world's leading countries in
most common type of geothermal powerterms of geothermal resources. Commercial
generation plants in operation today. They usepower generation from geothermal resources
water at temperatures greater than 182°Cbegan in Italy in 1913 with a 250 kW unit at
that is pumped under highpressure to theLarderello. Subsequently, the main emphasis has
generation equipment at the surface. Uponbeen on the production of power. Geothermal
reaching the generation equipment, the pressure iselectric power generating capacity in Italy has
suddenly reduced, allowing some of the hot waterreached 791 MW with four geothermal power
to convert or "flash" into steam.plants in 2005.
This steam is then used to power the turbineThe geothermal development has been almost
generator units to produce electricity. Binary cycleentirely privately funded. Since 1985, $US 280
geothermal power generation plants differ frommillion has been spent on R&D and $US 1254
dry steam and flash steam systems in that themillion on field development. Of these funds, 99%
water or steam from the geothermal reservoirwere obtained from private sources and only 1%
never comes in contact with the turbinewas derived from public sources.
generator units but is used to heat anotherMexico
"working fluid" which is vaporised and used to turnMexico is one of the fastest growing geothermal
the turbine/generator units.producers in the world. Twenty-seven geothermal
Geothermal power projects require high capitalpower plants are operating in the three Mexican
investment for exploration, drilling wells andfields, with total geothermal capacity of 953 MW
installation of plant, but have low operating costsin December 2005. There is a project to install 75
because of the low marginal cost of fuel. ReturnMW in 2006-2008 in the new area La Primavera
on investment is not achieved as quickly as withpending resolution of some environmental matters.
cheaper fossil fuel power plant, but longer termCFE has programmed to increase capacity in
economic benefits accrue from the use of thisCerro Prieto (100 MW) and Los Humeros (25 MW)
indigenous fuel source.in 2010.
Construction costs of geothermal plants can varyDirect uses of geothermal heat are widespread in
widely, depending on local conditions and rangeMexico, including industrial laundries, refrigeration,
from a minimum of $1.1 million to $ 3 million perdistrict and greenhouse heating, and fruit and
megawatt. The DOE has calculated an averagewood drying.
cost of $1.68 million for geothermal plants built inJapan
the Northwest of America in the last two years,The first experimental geothermal power
where the bulk of US plants are situated orgeneration in Japan took place in 1925 in Beppu
planned. However, while this is high incomparisonand capacity reached 535 MW in December 2005,
with gas power, which can be as low as $460,000which ranks Japan sixth in the world. The
per megawatt, the operating cost can be lowergovernment target for the year 2010 is installed
because there is no cost of fuel.geothermal capacity of 2,800MW. The plants
The leaders in developing geothermal technologyrange in size from the 65 MW Yanaizu-Nishiyama
and installing new plants are three Americanunit to the 100 kW Kirishima International Hotel
companies - Calpine, Unocal and Ormat, and oneback- pressure generator in Beppu, Kyushu.
Japanese company- Marubeni. These companiesThe Japanese government gives substantial
have been active in establishing joint ventures insupport to the development of geothermal
the Philippines and Indonesia and more recently inpower. ANRE, the Agency for Natural Resources
Central America.and Energy is playing a core role in development
USAand utilisation of geothermal energy in Japan, such
In December 2005 the installed geothermalas providing subsidy. NEDO plays a central role to
capacity in the USA was 2,564 MW, of whichsupport renewables and after a slow start is now
1,935 MW was usable. The considerable differencepromoting geothermal development as an element
between installed capacity and operating capacityof the concept of regional renewable integrated
in the USA was due to lack of steam caused byself-sufficient systems. The introduction and
over-exploitation of the Geysers geothermal fieldpromotion of geothermal energy as an alternative
in California. On this site, available steam can nowfor petroleum, has been its major task.
only supply 888 MW out of the 1,421 MW installedThe organisation is also encouraging international
capacity.cooperation relating to geothermal engineering.
Current geothermal resources using today'sOther countries
technology are estimated at 6,520 MW and atA further 16 countries have geothermal
22,000 MW with enhanced technology.generating facilities of varying size, ranging from
Over the last three decades, the US geothermalunder 500 kW in Argentina to 435 MW in New
power-generation industry has grown to be theZealand. Many of the smaller countries have higher
largest in the world, with over 2,445 MW ofdirect use.
installed electrical capacity. Growth during the first