Southern California Oaks Under Attack

Oak trees in the back country of eastern SanIn the Letters to the Editor section of the Back
Diego County are under attack by a beetleCountry Messenger, September '08 edition, Lake
presumed to be relatively new to California andMorena Village resident Jerry De Lucia described
not previously connected to the deaths of thesethe problem he had with his oak trees dying. He
types of trees in this area. Only very recently hastried increasing water to the trees which was a
the correlation to the dying trees and the rarerecommended solution. It did not work. He
shiny green oak borer been made. It is difficult tobecame increasingly concerned he would loose all
determine at this time the exact number of trees22 trees on his property when he was
infested and killed by this pest, but it is thought torecommended to Mr. Sole.
be a spreading problem affecting perhapsA treatment regimen was initiated on the dying
hundreds of square miles.oaks consisting of spraying them at intervals with
The connection was discovered somewhatthe liquid blend of worm tea and yucca extract.
inadvertently by United States Forest ServiceResults were quickly noticeable and it appears to
entomologist Tom Coleman while investigatinghave brought the infested trees back from what
widespread damage to oaks in the Clevelandwas a sure death. De Lucia claims in the article
National Forest where many trees were dyingthat his trees, after treatment, recovered and
from what was assumed to be the drought"almost looked like four years ago" - before he
conditions of recent years in Southern California.noticed any problems. He further states "If your
Coleman instead noticed that the trees weretrees look like they are dying, I highly recommend
under some sort of aggressive insect attack andNature's Big Bud (Worm Castings) Premium
subsequently discovered the culprit - which may(100% Organic Liquid) Plant Food." Apparently the
be named the Gold-spotted Oak Borer (Agrilustreatment made a believer out of him.
Coxalis). Oaks were infested with the beetle -Nature's Big Bud Worm Castings Field Tech,
drought was most likely not the primary cause ofRichard Buck, has been spraying trees at Legacy
tree deaths although it may have been aRanch and surrounding areas. He has had great
contributor.results with the liquid blend. (He also has tested it
In a press release dated August 15, 2008 theon trees affected by Sudden Oak Death, a
Forest Service formally announced the discoverypathenogenic disease involving a fungus-like
and the nature of the widespread problem citingbacterial infection and claims good results in
the cause officially as the wood boring beetle.treating it.)
According to the press release: "Evidence ofAs an aside and a warning to unsuspecting
insect attacks on oak trees can be seen by theresidents of the area, a so-called tree ‘expert'
presence of the insect under the bark, D-shapedfrom out of area has been wandering the back
exit holes in the bark, woodpecker foraging, andcountry in the vicinity of Cuyamaca (and probably
bark staining on the trunk of the tree and largerother rural places) offering to spray trees with a
branches."spectricide chemical - at an outrageous price. The
The infestation seems to be confined to theU.S. Forest Service has not recognized this nor
eastern part of the county although nowany chemicals as an effective treatment at this
spreading over what appears to be a wideningpoint to kill this particular beetle. Residents are
area. It is estimated as many as 70% of thewarned not to be taken in by any opportunists as
trees in the locale may be bug-ridden withof now. When a treatment method is approved,
mortality rates nearing 10%.I'm certain the Forest Service will let people know.
The oaks are the primary trees of manyAnd, it would be wise to only deal with known
landowners and are, in some cases, over aand reputable local businesses vice traveling
hundred years old, some even older. Local‘flimflammers'!
residents are concerned that they will lose theirThe loss of these trees is far more than an
trees to the beetle and are looking for ways toesthetics matter. Large scale deaths of the oaks
treat them.will contribute to soil erosion problems, increased
The Forestry Service is working on a plan forfuel for wildfires, and loss of habitat for varied
2009; they have held public meetings around thewildlife. The infestation is a growing threat over a
county since October of last year to get thelarge area with potentially devastating results. Let's
word out on the pest and measures which can behope the Forest Service and other related
taken to treat for it and, importantly, prevent itsagencies will find a solution to the problem soon.
spreadPerhaps they should contact Mr. Lonnie M. Sole of
In Campo, California, one rancher, Lonnie Sole, isCampo, California to confirm his ‘Go Green'
initiating his own proactive measures using a liquidorganic treatment method has merit rather than
blend of worm castings and yucca extract toresort to the customary use of harsh and
spray trees. His treatment, though not yetpolluting chemicals which will contribute to toxic
officially sanctioned by the State of California'srunoff into our waterways and underground
Department of Agriculture, appears to be workingwater supplies.
as he tests it on his own and his neighbors' trees.